Wednesday, August 13, 2008



After attaining independence from the British colonial regime on 15th August 1947, the indigenous Government of India soon began constituting a well defined administrative structure for the Andaman & Nicobar Islands.


The centre did provide for the Islands’ representation through a nominated Member of Parliament. Late Lachman Singh and then Lala Niranjan Lal were the members till 1967. Neither anything was expected of them nor did they contribute anything much significant.

Late K R Ganesh (standing third from right)

In 1967, late KR Ganesh, darling of the masses, was elected to the parliament with a thumping majority. People had very high hopes and expectations from him. But he was too preoccupied with his own ambitions. He did scale new heights in his career, first as a Deputy Minister and then as Minister of State in the Finance Ministry of the central government of India. He resigned as the emergency was lifted and contested as a candidate of Congress for Democracy, a Babu Jagjivan Ram outfit, and lost to Manoranjan Bhakta of Congress I. (See picture below)

Manoranjan Bhakta continues his marathon race till date but for a brief aberration during 1999-2004, when Bishnupada Ray of the BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party) was elected as the Member of Parliament. Like KR Ganesh, he too pursues his personal agenda. He has well for himself. There is no reason to believe that he has a vision for the development of the Islands. At least, since 1977 he has never spelt it out.

There was a semblance of power to the people for a brief period from 1982 to 1994 with a 30 member Pradesh Parishad. It was quietly abolished for no apparent reason. It was a tactical move to scuttle any competition at the top. It was a congress monopoly those days and hence there was no voice of protest.


Different people have different definitions of development. In A & N Islands, it is a central grant driven economy and hence, what one finds is – roads, bridges, buildings – too many of them, ships and harbours, schools and colleges, healthcare and all that goes with it. The quality of services rendered by these agencies is anybody’s guess.

Administration is the largest employer, the largest buyer and the largest construction agency. There is no industry. There were some plywood industries that packed off as a curb on tree felling was introduced. The economy revolves around traders and contractors who control the politics also. The money earned in the islands is invested in the mainland; consequently there is very little private effort to spur the economic activities.


Ostensibly to increase the pace of development, on August 01, 1974, the territory was divided into two districts by creating a new district of Nicobar comprising of all the islands in the Nicobar Group with its headquarters at Car Nicobar.

Similarly, a third district of North and Middle Andaman was created on August 18, 2006. But in spite of 33 years of its existence, the Nicobar district is a second grade entity. Apart from a deputy commissioner and a superintendent of police, there is nothing to distinguish it from other parts of the Islands.

The condition of North and Middle Andaman district is still worse. It rarely had a full time deputy commissioner for three months. Most of its brief existence, it shared its deputy commissioner and the superintendent of police with its big brother South Andaman district. It is a hoax played on the people of those flimsy districts. All the decision making powers are concentrated in the South Andaman district.


The administration for sometime past has been making noises in the national and international media about tourism as the mainstay of the Islands’ economy. It spends 2-3 crores of rupees on advertisement but is yet to evolve a transparent and practical tourism policy.

The other sunrise sector is touted to be fisheries and high value agriculture. But nobody in the administration has a clue how to go about it. Andaman Sea is the only sea in the world where fish die of old age whereas the administration spends millions on catching, prosecuting, feeding and transporting back the poachers from neighboring countries. About high value agriculture, the least said the better.


Till 1952, people entering A & N Islands were required to have an entry permit. But a free India could not restrict the free movement of its people. As a result, the population that stood at a mere 33,000 in 1951 leapfrogged to 3, 56,152 as per 2001 census. Unofficial estimates peg it at 5, 50,000.

Encroachment is the law in the territory. Anybody can encroach upon land anywhere he likes, be it revenue or forest of any description. People generally, are not stinking rich yet they manage. There is no grinding poverty per se. but all the poverty alleviation programs are implemented. Poor people from mainland flock to grab free land and the benefit of such programs. Politicians swell their vote bank and the bureaucrats look the other way.

Those 11,000 people who were left behind by SS Norilla on March 11, 1942 have been overwhelmed by the economic migrant. They have lost their identity. They don’t count in the scheme of things anymore.


On balance, things were not too bad if not very encouraging. Come December 26, 2004 and the entire equation changed. The devastating earthquake combined with the killer tsunami waves took heavy toll of lives and properties. Parts of the Islands were swallowed by the earthquake.

Thousands died and many more thousands simply disappeared from the face of the earth. The shock was too much, the pain too severe.

The tribal people of the Nicobar district had to suffer the most. Their world has changed forever. They are still living in temporary shelters. Life would not be the same again – not for the people of the Nicobar district.

The livelihood of old inhabitants is threatened in South Andaman. But nobody has any tears to spare for them. They don’t form the major vote bank anymore. They still live in a tunnel of despair waiting for the messiah who would deliver them.


  1. Hi Nice Blog .Linking will increase your seo indiaand writing articles with your main website address in the author's information area will provide a one way link which is the best link you can get. If you want your articles spread all over the internet with your one way link, paid article submission services are by far the best and easiest way to go.

  2. I chanced upon this blog and as I sit here thousands of miles away in the US, I cannot but remember with nostalgia the three years in the late 80's I spent in Port Blair.
    Its been 20 years since I left the islands but it still holds a special place in my heart. In those islands my grandmother gave birth to my mother during the japanese invasion. My mother sadly passed away a few years ago but I can still see her growing up there in the 40's and I can still see my Dad, when he first saw her there on assigment with the engineering services. Ah Mr. Vashistha, Thank you for the blog and the pictures. I have travelled the globe,and still think the beaches of Port Blair were amongst the most pristine I have seen. But like everything else, I hope the islands develop sustainably and stay unpolluted and a haven for wildlife. Too much development without proper infrastructure to support it can spell disaster. Keep up the good work. Post more pictures.

  3. @Travel Bug Oh, I reckon this is one the best comments I have ever received up here at my blog! Thanks a ton, dear Ms Rumi, for sharing your lovely and emotional thoughts and experiences with us here!

    I'm elated, to say the least, having learnt about you and your good family's endearingly close affinity with these exemplary historic islands and I, categorically, agree with all that you've so judiciously said about development here. Hope, the requisite is upheld by the authorities.

    Great to have met you, dear Ms Rumi! Hope to see you back here frequently to be able to hear more from you. Thanks again for making my day! Cheers & God bless! :-)

  4. Really sad to know about all these. Yes, I can understand their feelings. Hopefully... everything should get normal.

  5. You are helping raise awareness, and that alone is good and positive.

  6. @ASWANI Very true! "Hope" is what remains for these old inhabitants... Let's keep our fingers crossed for the best to happen for them, soon... Thank you!

    @Kathleen B. Thanks, dear Kathleen! I wish this alone could help take good care of the cause... I'd appreciate all those who help spread the word around about these islands. See you back here more often for more from you...!

  7. Thank you Mr.Vashsistha. I remember having a picture taken next an Ongee man when I was a child. Its was in the mid eighties. I thought it was the coolest thing. Ofcourse I grew up and learnt it was not. It breaks my heart that the true inhabitants of the island are on the brink of extinction. The world over indigenous people have disappeared without a trace.
    Alont with which are lost of languages, customs and thousands of survival skills. you are raising awareness which is the first road to keep them "away" from our civilization. Look at the true inhabitants of Australia the aborigines and what happened to them or the native americans and thier plight today. It might be too late to save them from extinction but atleast we can try.
    I will post your link on my blog.

  8. @Travel Bug
    Incoherent and callous policies of the government vis-a-vis these unsuspecting tribes always, has eventually led to such gloomy state of affairs. Your generous and passionate views are categorically true, dear Rumi! Love your sense of humanness! Thanks a bushel!